Good & Evil are two sides of a mirror; The pristine,
clear, reflective side that shows us our appearance is Good, but the dark
underbelly behind it…what is that?? Evil?? Or a counter reflection of You?? No
one person is all Evil & no one person is all Good. There are elements of
both in each one of us!! It is just a matter of time, which side of the mirror
overtakes us first, & becomes the part of our being, thereby shaping
actions & destiny of the course of future forever!!
Every thing that has happened or is happening has a
story…every such event has a reason!!!
When I was given Jagmohan Bhanver’s “The Curse of Brahma” to
read – the first instalment of his offering, THE KRISHNA TRILOGY, I honestly
thought, “Oh no!!! One more trilogy?? When will people stop LOTRising our Vedic
History into an over stylised fantasy fiction??!!” Yes, I have read almost all
the “bestselling” fantasy fics on Indian Purans & Epics, & have not
been impressed with any of them so far. I felt they were either too simplistic;
if not that, then too amateurish; if not even that, then too Americanised in
their language; if not that, then either unnecessarily sensational or too ho-hum.
I had not stumbled upon one wholesome work that gave me a perfect blend of
facts & fiction, all wrapped up in an interesting package; where neither is
the Vedic fact compromised, nor is characterisation compromised, nor is
fictional story around it irritating & cringe-worthy, like something
getting in your way.
The Curse of Brahma addresses each of these points with
great dexterity. As the name suggests, it is part of the Krishna Trilogy,
therefore it focuses on Krishna Leela, i.e, Dwapar Yug. The author, Jagmohan
Bhanver, takes his own pace & time to unfold his story. In fact, I did
wonder, what has Brahma got to do with Krishna’s story at all, isn’t that
Vishnu’s domain? ; & This is where Bhanver digresses you beautifully from
the facts given in the Puran to his own fictional story of how the big Dwapar Yug
drama unfolded.
In fact, the whole book is a perfect symmetry of fact &
fiction.
What sets Bhanver’s book apart from others in the same genre
is, that while most of the books use ready made facts & characters as main
plot line to start their work & weave the fictional story or character in
between the narrative as a secondary plot, Bhanver’s book takes the opposite
route. His primary characters or start of the story is purely via fiction, and
then slowly incorporates real characters & story back into his fictional
narrative to make complete sense of the whole story & where it is headed.
This, to my mind, was very brave of the author, as not only it involves
exercising your own creativity & not solely relying on ready made story
obtained from Purans; it also gives a different outlook & meaning as to why
the major events of Dwapar Yug actually happened, the end of which earmarked
the start of KaliYug.
I will not reveal too much about The Curse of Brahma as it
will end up divulging the spoilers of the book’s plot. But I will tell you what
to expect when reading this book:
· Original
story to kickstart the book: As the name suggests & the Book’s summary
suggests, it starts with the after effects of a curse given by Brahma that
shapes the destiny of future & propels the Sampoorna Avatar (Complete
incarnation) of Vishnu to come on Earth. I had not read about any such event in
Purans & was pleasantly surprised that Bhanver’s imagination did not
underwhelm the unfolding of actual events of Krishna Leela.
· Amartya Kalyanesu – Watch out for this
character!!! So much depth & dimension to explore in him!!
·
Conceptual
explanation: As is the norm with books of this genre, The Curse…also
explains some important concepts of cosmology & the Holy Trinity to make
absolute sense. They are not over the top nor are they underwhelming in their
explanantion.
·
Character
build up: Bhanver has given enough time & thought to build up his
characters & given reason as to why someone became how they are seen today in
the pages of History. It’s not a cardboard caricature like many books of this
genre easily slip into (take Amish’s Shiva Trilogy as an example: Sati is a
ferocious & strong willed warrior princess who fears no one & does not
think twice before wielding a sword, yet she gives into regressive practices
like Vikarma with absolute ease, believing she deserves to be ostracised for
“crimes” she has not even committed!! Or on one hand Daksha is willing to break
any law & do anything to protect his poor daughter from the fate of being a
widow; yet he plots to suddenly kill Shiva, irrespective that his daughter will
again be thrown into the same fate that he fought against in the first
instance; take Ashwin Sanghi’s The Krishna Key as an example – Tarak Vakil, the
main protagonist is this smooth serial killer who thinks he is the incarnation
of Krishna & is annihilating Evil through his murders…& then suddenly
this strong character turns into…into…something like Tarak Mehta ka Ulta
Chashma!!). Bhanver’s characters on the other hand stand firmly on their feet
& act & react exactly how they should, given their characterization. If
someone changes his or her colours, a valid explanation of that is also given
to make it look wholesome & logical.
·
Romance
Plots: I can say one thing very safely; most Indian authors (not all…mind
you), just cannot write romance with ease. Cannot!! And authors of this genre,
just cannot. It just does not come out naturally & looks like an effort.
It’s exactly how our film stars used to kiss on screen – cringing, like on a
gunpoint, like a chore that has to be done. Amish’s Shiva Trilogy (especially
the first book) made a difficult read for me solely because of this reason;
Shiva & Sati romance (where even the serial Mahadev could do a good job)
was so cringe worthy & “trying too hard”. Ashwin Sanghi’s Krishna Key
romance was similar & a total washout; Anand Neelakanthan’s Ajaya track of
Karna - Draupdai & Duryodhana- Subhadra was laughable!!! Compared to that
romance plots were few in Bhanver’s book but well developed, subtle & came
in as a matter of fact. The Devki & Vasudev romance was nowhere cringing in
nature & nor were side plot romance tracks. The important part was, that
while these tracks were there, they were not causing an impediment to the main
plot, but were simply contributing to it.
·
Thrilling
build up: The book is a thriller for sure!! The plot of the book thickens
into thrilling events one after the other. Whether it is the fight sequences or
events mentioned in the Purans, they have been given a wonderfully ominous
feel. You can almost feel such events unfolding right in front of your eyes.
The fight sequences are especially worth mentioning; they themselves have a
character of their own.
Another thing that caught my interest was
how Bhanver delved into gore when required (not unnecessarily or too much) to
create significant amount of pathos. His description of Tamastamah Prabha – the
Hell of Hells was eerie & pathos inducing. However, he did not delve so
much into it either, as to take away from the main plot of the book. His focus &
commitment to the story was always there.
To sum it up Bhanver’s The
Curse of Brahma is Thrilling, Intelligent, Pacy, Brave & laced with a
strong narrative. It works on its own fictional plot first & then smartly
weaves in the events mentioned in Purans….and boy does it deliver!!!
I just hope the rest two books in Bhanver’s Krishna Trilogy live upto the pitch
at which this book takes you as a reader!!
A MUST READ!!
Publication: Rupa
Available on Flipkart & all leading book
stores.
(Disclaimer: This is not a paid article; the views expressed
in this review are blogger’s own opinion)
hi, I am kitabikida.wordpress.com, so hello from one kida to the other.
ReplyDeleteout of curiosity what was laughable about Draupadi-Karna or Duryodhana-Subhadra? my personal opinion of the track be whatever.
ReplyDeleteHi Sharmila, nice to say hello to another Kida. Aren't books the best?? :)
ReplyDeleteTo answer your next question...frankly i have kind of forgotten the book by now. All i can recall & say is that analysis & interpretations of epics are good...but interpretation for the heck of it makes no sense to me. Our epics are not just stories, they are highly scientific purports of knowledge that map sociological, psychological behaviour of humanity. That is the reason that their charm has simply not faded over millenia. This version of Neelakantan was laughable, because even in his own interpretation it could match up to that stature. Sure, give me a 360 degree spin...but don't make it so underwhelming. Even historically a Duryodhan & Subadhra spin is quite unrealistic. Duryodhan was much older than Subadhra & already married by the time Balram took her hand in marriage to him. Historically marriages in royalty was about alliances and not love. Pick up any history & map it, u will find the same. Duryodhan was interested in marrying Subadhra only for a political alliance & so was Arjun...there is nothing bad in that, as this is how it used to be always. Then, this particular version seemed very laughable to me. I honestly do not remember Karna & Draupadi episode as described in Neelakanthan's book by now. Hope that answers your question :)
Also to add...Ramayan & Mahabharat are not J.K.Rowling's books that someone should spark fanfiction tales around it. One, while giving interpretation, has to rise above a simple story & read the underlying message that shapes human behaviour & the give a version. Pairing anyone for the heck of it makes it look like fanfiction pairing.
ReplyDeleteHi Sharmila, nice to say hello to another Kida. Aren't books the best?? :)
ReplyDeleteTo answer your next question...frankly i have kind of forgotten the book by now. All i can recall & say is that analysis & interpretations of epics are good...but interpretation for the heck of it makes no sense to me. Our epics are not just stories, they are highly scientific purports of knowledge that map sociological, psychological behaviour of humanity. That is the reason that their charm has simply not faded over millenia. This version of Neelakantan was laughable, because even in his own interpretation it could match up to that stature. Sure, give me a 360 degree spin...but don't make it so underwhelming. Even historically a Duryodhan & Subadhra spin is quite unrealistic. Duryodhan was much older than Subadhra & already married by the time Balram took her hand in marriage to him. Historically marriages in royalty was about alliances and not love. Pick up any history & map it, u will find the same. Duryodhan was interested in marrying Subadhra only for a political alliance & so was Arjun...there is nothing bad in that, as this is how it used to be always. Then, this particular version seemed very laughable to me. I honestly do not remember Karna & Draupadi episode as described in Neelakanthan's book by now. Hope that answers your question :)